Comments for Gimmick Guide Revision

From TRCWiki
Revision as of 18:58, 3 February 2010 by Dean (talk | contribs) (Sorted existing sections into done and to be considered)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Dean is currently updating TRC's Coursemarker Gimmick Rallye Guide for our February, 2010, membership rallye (our 30th year!). This is a page for suggestions of things to improve (add, remove, clarify, etc.).

Current Draft

The current draft is File:CM Guide 3.1 1-18draft.pdf. You can print it as a brochure (11 duplex sheets) using Acrobat Reader's Print options.

Changes to Discuss or Consider

Include A/B Rallye Info?

Dean would eventually like to add A/B rallye information and make the guide a Gimmick Rallye Guide rather than specific to coursemarker rallyes, but does not expect to attempt this prior to February's rallye.

Checklist?

Someone asked for a checklist to use at the start. I don't know if one could be both sufficiently complete and sufficiently brief. I also wonder if it would be too easy to raise everyone's scores; would a checklist be "cheating"?


Changes Made in 3.1 Edition (from Third Ed.)

TRC Club Info

The back page of the CM Guide has info on the club that is easily outdated:

  • membership fees
  • starting location
  • start, class, and finish times
  • business meeting day, time, and location

Dean is correcting most of this (and removing the rest). Readers should use the web page to get current information. Access to the World Wide Web is much more ubiquitous than it was 5 years or more ago, when the Guide was last updated.

Replaced "School Rallye"?

Dean replaced the "School Rallye" near the end of the Rallye Guide, primarily because the expert gimmick where you are ONTO but not physically on the road with that name is more difficult to grasp than it needs to be. The concept of an RI being completed twice -- once by execution and once by deletion -- is important, but need not be handcuffed to this odd ONTO form. Dean used TRC's current "School Rallye" instead. Darin made it easy, so I did this for February's rallye. Except I kept the old score sheet, because it was far easier.


I agree. IME, completing the RI a second time when CRI deletes it is already an advanced gimmick. Further complicating this gimmick by putting them "onto" when they are not actually on the named road is an unnecessary complication in a normal rallye, and is really overkill in a school rallye.
- Darin McGrew 20:43, 11 January 2010 (UTC)

Rallye Terms

Dean beefed up the Guide's definitions (at the back). It is now 2 pages. Differentiate "At," "After," "On," and "Onto" (was already there). Deleted "Giz" for "Gimmick." Added several terms that were defined earlier in the Guide, such as "Critique," and a few issues I couldn't find a better place to discuss (parentheses and quotation marks).

Things to Bring to Rallye

Dean did add to the back cover (under Usual Rallye Start) things to bring to a rallye. The back is a little cramped now.

Retrieved from "http://wiki.therallyeclub.org/w/index.php?title=Comments_for_Gimmick_Guide_Revision&oldid=804"